Inside Music: Consumer Guide
Consumer Guide by Robert Christgau (Images: Beck/GEFFEN, Arcade Fire/MERGE, Nas/DEF JAM)
advertisement

More: Reviews | Honorable Mention | Dud of the Month

MORE REVIEWS

Nils Petter Molvaer: 'ER' (Thirsty Ear)

Nils Petter Molvær
"ER"
(Thirsty Ear)

On the spookiest of Thirsty Ear's three Molvær albums, Molvær's Miles-sans-mute sound -- smooth the way strawberry sherbet is smooth -- floats through buzzes and washes, squiggles and treated voices, bodied up by bass parts often his own. Not that he's a loner -- most tracks feature four to six samplers, programmers, drummers and such. Here's hoping the woman who sings (and wrote) "Only These Things Count" is another respected fellow professional, rather than his girlfriend. Miles reserved his girlfriends for cover shots.

Grade: A MINUS


Nils Petter Molvaer: 'Streamer' (Thirsty Ear)

Nils Petter Molvær
"Streamer"
(Thirsty Ear)

Recorded at a Jan. 1, 2002, Finnish concert where some audience members surely dozed briefly unless the heat was on the fritz, this is pretty lulling for a live album -- assuming the ground of your being isn't threatened by guitar blats, jungle beats and noises that poke out of the flow like tree branches and old car parts. It includes five compositions that had just then surfaced on "NP3," only here they're gauzier. Due to the spoken-word snatches the trumpeter strews on top, they're also eerier. But not, I promise, scarier.

Grade: A MINUS


Nas: 'Hip Hop Is Dead' (Def Jam)

Nas
"Hip Hop Is Dead"
(Def Jam)

I wouldn't take him at his word -- especially when he says he's not going back to a street life there's no evidence he ever had knocked in the first place -- and I doubt he knows as much as claimed about the perks of his Escobar hustle: "watchin' fly bitches with grey eyes wrestle in a tub of KY," escaping a shoot-out with his milkshake wife, etc. The fun comes easier when he fools around with the title conceit, and even sometimes when he thinks about it. Rhyming "orange" with "showin'" and "pawn it," rapping in fake Bogie, playing the "black militant" to his former adversary and current sponsor's "black Republican," naming so many lost rappers I needed a hankie (Special Ed! Tim Dog! Fu-Schnickens! Shante!), he wants us to know he's an old-school MF who can afford efficiently state-of-the-art beats. Big worry: "Can't sound smart 'cause you'll run away." What to do, what to do?

Grade: A MINUS


7L & Esoteric: 'A New Dope' (Babygrande)

7L & Esoteric
"A New Dope"
(Babygrande)

In which the Boston duo, known insofar as they're known at all for Premier-they-wish beats and metaphor-is-murder battle rhymes, lightens up on a basically satirical CD. "Get Dumb" sets the intellectually hyphy tone: "Billie Holiday he's the best/That cool band Beck is touring out West," or, "Bin Laden he's only bluffin'/She's on the pill so I won't catch nothin'." Esoteric treats himself to lists, similes and sexual contretemps. 7L injects scratches and drum breaks into Middle Eastern flutes, porn loops and suspense-movie music. Indie-rap lives.

Grade: A MINUS


The Thermals: 'The Body, the Blood, the Machine' (Sub Pop)

The Thermals
"The Body, the Blood, the Machine"
(Sub Pop)

As narrative and prophecy, a less coherent response to Christofascism than you might want, but one alt needs, held together and moved ahead by its forthright hooks and beats. On timbre alone, Hutch Harris might almost be some emo boy bewailing his romantic ignominy. Instead he attacks the Bush-Cheney axis, naming said villains in the public prints. And though I dread his promised devolution album, I admire him for knowing that the couple he chronicles can run and even hide but can't actually escape.

Grade: A MINUS


Tom Waits: 'Orphans: Brawlers, Bawlers, and Bastards' (Anti-)

Tom Waits
"Orphans: Brawlers, Bawlers, and Bastards"
(Anti-)

Having creamed for these 56 songs old, new and nobody's talking, I returned with trepidation. Sure enough, the first time through, too many had faded on me. Soon, however, even ones I'd given up on were bum-rushing my earhole, like "Lucinda," with its steel-driving beat and gallows gloom. One reason, close attention to 1988's "Sea of Love" suggests, is that his groan has grown more distinct. And though it would be mere rhetoric to claim the six spoken-word pieces on Disc 3 are really music -- they're yarns, jokes, theater, that's the point -- they do really sound good. I said sound.

Grade: A


Tom Zé: 'Danc-Eh-Sa' (Irara)

Tom Zé
"Danc-Eh-Sa"
(Irara)

Showing a purity of purpose generally lacking in operettas, here are seven tracks lasting barely half an hour, every one insanely and sometimes gratingly catchy, with choruses femme and otherwise singing, whistling, moaning, jeering, barking and meowing the tunes — as well as embellishing rhythms dominated by electronic whatsits of every description except techno. Since it's beats and sonics that draw non-Lusophones to Zé's oddball tropicalia, world-music honchos will soon be speed-dialing his cellie. Psych.

Grade: A MINUS

More: Reviews | Honorable Mention | Dud of the Month

Subscribe to this feed Subscribe to this feed | Join the discussion | Send us an e-mail

advertisement
Consumer Guide Archive
MSN Music Newsletter
Get weekly updates on hot new releases; listen to full albums; watch videos and much more

Subscribe to the newsletter
video vault
Watch 'Na Na Na Na' by 112112: 'Na Na Na Na'
See Lil Wayne, M83, Amy MacDonald, Nelly and more

PlayWatch video | More videos
Top Search
Search for more on Mick Jagger (Image: Mick Jagger/Paul Cox/Atlantic)Mick Jagger
Mick Jagger and the Rolling Stones jump to the top

Search | More Celebrity xRank
In Concert
Alanis Morissette in Concert (Image: Alanis Morissette/WEA)Alanis Morissette
Watch her concert from Carling Academy Brixton performed June 19, 2008

Watch | More Concerts

Top galleries
Top features